An asset based advisory fee is a charge set by the size of the assets a firm manages, or by a client's net worth, instead of by the work involved[1]. Richard C. Wilson writes that in some cases this is valid[1]. He also writes that it may not always feel good on the receiving end[1].
It can be a great business to charge based on AUM, but it may not always be a nice feeling on the receiving end.
How the fee is set
Richard C. Wilson describes one area of overcharging as fees based on Assets Under Management, or net worth[1]. Notes from a Family Office Club event list fees based on AUM, and not on work needed, as a concern[2]. Reporting is given as one example[2].
In the investment space, Richard C. Wilson writes, almost everyone wants to charge 10 times more for a family worth $300M than for one worth $30M[1]. The larger family may be only three times as complex or five times as much work to serve[1]. This is partly because complex situations can arise[1]. It is also partly because providers know a family can afford it[1].
Where families see it
Richard C. Wilson did research for multiple providers of reporting software[1]. Richard C. Wilson writes that no provider known to the author posts pricing guidance on its website[1]. Providers do ask about AUM size, industry focus, and type of organization[1].
At a Family Office Club event, fee creep was named as a headache that can begin even before a family office is formed[2]. When people hear that a family is worth a certain amount, they may ratchet up their fees[2]. The question was asked whether accounting takes 90 times longer for a $900 million family than for a $10 million family[2]. With 10 LLCs, the answer could be yes[2].
What families do about it
Richard C. Wilson writes that very wealthy families have more bargaining power than they may realize[1]. The point is not to pay less[1]. It is to get an effective compounded return from invested capital and avoid wasting it[1]. Many investment fund managers and firms want to attract clients of that stature[1]. Some would accept discounted fees or a creative structure that aligns both sides[1].
Richard C. Wilson also writes that a family may ask for performance only fees instead of reduced fees[1]. Then the family does not pay when the manager loses money, or loses money against a benchmark set together[1]. At a Family Office Club event, one fund was described with no acquisition fee and no annual asset management fee[2]. Investors get their money back, plus double, before fees are earned[2]. Some investors still preferred the normal structure[2].
Notes from a Family Office Club event also say that negotiating fees can pay for a family office on its own[2]. Richard C. Wilson writes that advisors may point toward a solution that also benefits them[3].
Common questions
What is fee creep?
At a Family Office Club event, fee creep was described as fees rising once people hear what a family is worth[2]. It can begin even before a family office is formed[2].
What is a performance only fee?
Richard C. Wilson writes that it means a family does not pay when the manager loses money, or loses money against a benchmark set together[1].
Do families negotiate fees?
Richard C. Wilson writes that many investment firms want to earn the business of clients of that stature, even with discounted fees or a creative structure[1].
Related questions and guides
- How can a family stop paying fees on assets that need no work?
- What is a family office advisory board?
- How do I negotiate fees with a wealth manager?
- Why should a family narrow its investment focus?
- Understand asset based fees
- Compare retainer and project fees
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice.
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies, Chapter 3: FEEING Frenzy
- Family Office Club event transcript (Richard C. Wilson)
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies, Chapter 2: Control Conflicts