Centimillionaire families often face significant control conflicts when managing their portfolios and direct investments[1][2]. Most first generation creators of wealth built their capital through direct control of operating businesses or real estate portfolios[2]. Documenting governance policies, including the approval process before an investment is made, can help these families clarify expectations and keep oversight of their investments[2][3].
From Centimillionaire Strategies, Chapter 2: Control Conflicts, by Richard C. Wilson.
It is important in your governance documentation to talk about how you manage changes to your investment policy. What is the approval process before an investment is made?
Sources of Control Conflicts and the Need for Governance Policies
First generation families typically built their assets by actively building real estate portfolios, acquiring companies, or directing their own operating businesses[2]. Because of this background, founders naturally resist handing their assets to third parties or accepting modest returns without retaining oversight[2]. Richard C. Wilson notes that inherent conflicts are likely embedded in the setup and operations of a family's organization and advisors[1][4].
Richard C. Wilson notes that sprawling families often face complex, emotionally charged decisions, and that objective rules set up early help prevent bitterness from perceived favoritism[3]. In one case study of a one hundred and seventy million dollar family, the family employed a chief executive officer earning four hundred and twenty five thousand dollars a year plus incentives and paid one million dollars annually for overhead staff[1]. Despite having accounts with three wealth management firms, the office lacked performance reports, investment analytics, and clarity on its overall strategy[1].
Formal investment and portfolio management documentation outlines the exact approval process required before capital is deployed[3][5]. These policies specify who holds the authority to decide asset allocation percentages between asset classes such as real estate, private equity, hedge funds, or commodities[5].
Defining the Investment Strike Zone and Allocation Buckets
To manage deal flow effectively, Richard C. Wilson teaches families to document a precise investment strike zone[4]. In a case study of a one hundred million dollar branch of a larger five hundred million dollar family, operating without documented values, missions, or criteria caused the office to pursue random ideas from local referrals[4]. Implementing a twelve point investment criterion allowed the family to clearly communicate to advisors and staff exactly what opportunities they would review, consider, or proactively pursue[4].
A practical one page deal flow document captures these core direct investment parameters[6]. This tool records the direct investment mission, family values, network resources, one to three target industry focus areas, and overall portfolio size limits[6]. It also defines minimum years in business, minimum earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, control preferences regarding minority or majority stakes, and debt, equity, or royalty structures[6].
Families also evaluate operational control across three investment buckets: diversified assets, cash flowing commercial real estate, and operating businesses[1]. For each bucket, the office defines whether it will retain complete control or outsource specific tasks[1]. These distinct responsibilities include strategy, sourcing, screening, due diligence, negotiation, and asset management[1].
Structuring Due Diligence Controls and Minority Approval Rights
Governance documentation must define controls that ensure proper due diligence takes place on every transaction[3][5]. Families use tools like the six Cs to confirm that external partners and advisors align with family values and demonstrate high character quality[1]. Objective key performance indicators should also be tracked daily or weekly for staff members from the executive level down to analysts to ensure accountability across family and non-family personnel[5].
When taking minority positions in direct investments, families often require binding legal commitments to protect their interests[7]. These super-majority terms prevent the company management and majority owners from taking specific actions without prior express minority approval[7]. Essential pre-agreed protections include input on management changes for poor performance, approval of annual business plans and budgets, prohibitions on related-party dealings, selection of independent auditors and legal counsel, control over capital movements into and out of the business, clear exit rights, deadlock resolution steps, and binding arbitration[7].
Governance rules must also enforce strict protocols for identifying and resolving conflicts of interest[7][3]. Pre-closing, any potential member conflict must be disclosed in writing to all participants upfront[7]. Post-closing, all conflicts and related-party dealings require disclosure to and formal approval by the board[7].
Aligning Decisions Across Family Members and Advisors
Richard C. Wilson recommends using structured evaluation tools to orient family thinking around control[1]. Completing a ten minute quiz and a fifty kickoff questions document helps family members clarify their personal control preferences[1]. Draft versions of control tables should be completed to assign authority levels across different family assets and responsibilities[1].
Families refine their governance logic by engaging in structured discussions[1]. Richard C. Wilson advises discussing control preferences with at least two family members and five total individuals[1]. This discussion helps refine the family's ideas and reasoning for its decisions[1].
Put it into practice
- Complete the fifty kickoff questions document and ten minute quiz to evaluate personal control preferences.
- Draft a portfolio table defining internal control versus outsourcing for diversified assets, commercial real estate, and operating businesses across strategy, sourcing, screening, due diligence, negotiation, and management.
- Document a direct investment one page summary detailing target industries, minimum years in business, minimum EBITDA, and debt, equity or royalty preferences.
- Implement a formal twelve point investment criterion to screen incoming deal flow and direct proactive sourcing.
- Establish binding super-majority approval rights on business plans, budgets, management changes, and capital movements for any minority investment.
- Require written upfront disclosure of all potential conflicts of interest and mandate board approval for any post-closing related-party transactions.
- Review draft approval thresholds and control policies with at least two family members and five trusted individuals total.
Worksheets and calculators for this step
Common questions
Why do first generation centimillionaire families experience control conflicts after a liquidity event?
First generation wealth creators typically built their assets through direct control of operating businesses and real estate[2]. They naturally resist handing over total authority to outside managers or accepting modest returns without retaining oversight[2].
What specific approval rights protect family offices when making minority direct investments?
Families negotiate binding super-majority terms requiring prior express approval for annual budgets, business plans, capital movements, management changes, and related-party transactions[7].
How should investment conflicts of interest be handled within family office governance?
Potential conflicts of interest must be disclosed in writing upfront before closing[7]. Following closing, any ongoing conflicts or related-party dealings must be disclosed to and approved by the board[7].
Related guides
- Draft an investment committee charter
- Set family office decision rights
- Separate owner and operator roles
- Separate family and business decisions
- Why should a family narrow its investment focus?
- Who should sit on a family office investment committee?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice.
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies, Chapter 2: Control Conflicts
- Family Office Club event transcript (Richard C. Wilson)
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies, Chapter 1: Blurred Vision
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office: Direct Investments edition
- Richard C. Wilson, Direct Investing
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office